Aim: Southampton splinting is a form of isometric traction splinting of the digits for the management of phalangeal fractures. The digit is reduced through manipulation and traction and held with taping and an aluminium splint construct in the position of function until fracture healing allows motion out of a splint. Despite successful published results historically, there has been a paradigm shift towards open reduction and internal fixation for the management of unstable phalangeal fractures. In our institution, Southampton splinting has remained a valuable tool in the management of selected phalangeal fractures. The aim of our study was to review our management of unstable phalangeal fractures using the Southampton splint, and to report the radiographic and functional outcomes.
Methods: We retrospectively collected data for all proximal and middle phalanx fractures managed in a Southampton splint from January 2019 to January 2024 within Te Whatu Ora Bay of Plenty hospitals. Patients were included if splinting was the definitive form of treatment for their fracture. Radiographs were reviewed by two observers and instability documented. Open fractures, skeletally immature patients and patients followed up out of region were excluded. Patients who crossed over to the operative group were also excluded. We carried out phone consultations on those contactable to determine post treatment function and DASH scores.
Results: There were 42 patients included; 21 females and 21 males, and 43 digits. There were 31 proximal phalanx and 12 middle phalanx fractures included. Mean age was 44.48 years (15-82). 34/42 (81%) were low-energy mechanism. Mean time of splinting was 3.2 weeks (range 1-6). 18/42 (43%) patients required re-manipulation at a mean of 7 days (range 1-14 days). [SM1.1]85% of fractures were defined as unstable at the time of initial injury. Our data showed radiographic signs of union across all patients, with satisfactory radiographic and clinical alignment in 41/43 digits (95.3%), including those considered unstable. 22/42 patients (52%) were contactable post treatment. The mean DASH score was 8.58 (range 0-43.3). 1/22 patients had clinically significant rotational deformity post splinting. Only 2/22 (9%) failed to return to their former employment following their injury, one of whom had a physically demanding job. The main complications were re-manipulation and poorly tolerated splints.
Conclusion: Southampton splinting has been shown to be a satisfactory form of treatment for selected unstable proximal and middle phalanx fractures. Judicious use and careful application of the Southampton splint negates operative risks and may have clinical and financial advantages, but does require careful clinical follow-up. Further research into a comparison study between non-operatively managed and operatively managed cohorts would be beneficial.